All-Region / All-American Honors
Rider Softball All-Region Selections
| Terry Gillespie | 1989 |
| Terry Gillespie | 1991 |
| Dana DeSimone | 1993 |
| Sandy Stringham | 1993 |
| Dana DeSimone | 1994 |
| Sandy Stringham | 1994 |
| Jen Repkoe | 1994 |
| Michelle Peel | 2000 |
| Deanna Dovak | 2000 |
| Deanna Dovak | 2001 |
| Deanna Dovak | 2002 |
| Maddy Boulden | 2004 |
| Amanda Tu | 2004 |
| Heather Beintema | 2004 |
Rider Softball All-Americans
| Deanna Dovak | 2001 |
